Register    Calendar    Members    ST Team    Forum Search    FAQ    Portal    Overview

Silgrad.com The Gallery Books & Stories Download the Silgrad Tower mod Chat Broad silgrad.com search Forum Portal Frequently Asked Questions Maps of our Lands
Silgrad Tower: Oblivion » Beyond Cyrodiil » Skyrim for Oblivion » Skyrim Quests » The Order of Oak and Thorn » Hello You
Last Post | First Unread Post Print Page | Recommend to a Friend | Add Thread to Favorites
This is an archived forum. Post Reply
Go to the bottom of this page The Order of Oak and Thorn
Author
Post « Previous Thread | Next Thread »
Siegfried
Archduke


images/avatars/avatar-3174.jpg

Registration Date: 07.03.2006
Posts: 2,598
Location: With Your Mom...

The Order of Oak and Thorn Reply to this Post Post Reply with Quote Edit/Delete Posts Report Post to a Moderator       Go to the top of this page

Alright, lets talk factions.

The Order of Oak and Thorn is an organization or Nordic Druids, Shamans, hunters, and Rangers responsible for carrying out the various religious rituals and ceremonies that compose the Nordic Faith. Generally, these ceremonies are carried out in rings of standing stones deep within the forests of Skyrim.

So lets kick around some ideas, what would people like to see in this faction?
15.06.2007 08:40 Siegfried is offline Search for Posts by Siegfried Add Siegfried to your Buddy List
Psychotic
Jarl of Skyrim


images/avatars/avatar-1933.jpg

Registration Date: 30.07.2006
Posts: 3,420
Location: Sheogorath's Realm

Reply to this Post Post Reply with Quote Edit/Delete Posts Report Post to a Moderator       Go to the top of this page

Before I add ideas of my own I have a few questions:
- What is the purpose of the order? Do they seek to spiritually guide the people of Skyrim or do they do what they do only for themselves?
- If the order does serve the people to some extent how do they (the people) interact with the order and how do they participate in the rituals of the order (Do they go to the local stone circle on Sundas to dance and drink in honor of the gods? :D )?
- Does the order claim to be able to communicate with the gods and if so is this claim real?
- Does the order favor one Nordic god over all other or are they all equally worshiped and respected?
- In Nordic lore only shamans are mentioned (AFAIK), what's the difference between shamans and druids?
- What kind of a role do rangers play in the order?
- Precisely what kind of rituals and ceremonies does the order perform (A ritual for a longer summer perhaps?)?
- Can the powers of the order be related to magic or is there another way of explaining it (since magic is not very popular with Nords)?
- Is there a conflict between The Order of Oak and Thorn and the Mages' Guild/Imperial Cult? If there is one what exactly is the source of that conflict (a question with an obvious answer perhaps)?

That's all the questions I can think of atm, I hope they will inspire some creative answers. :)
15.06.2007 22:38 Psychotic is offline Send an Email to Psychotic Search for Posts by Psychotic Add Psychotic to your Buddy List Add Psychotic to your Contact List View the MSN Profile for Psychotic
Alasdair
Jarl of Skyrim


images/avatars/avatar-2926.gif

Registration Date: 29.08.2006
Posts: 1,169
Location: Somerset, England

Reply to this Post Post Reply with Quote Edit/Delete Posts Report Post to a Moderator       Go to the top of this page

quote:
Originally posted by Psychotic
- Is there a conflict between The Order of Oak and Thorn and the Mages' Guild/Imperial Cult? If there is one what exactly is the source of that conflict (a question with an obvious answer perhaps)?

I'd image there would be conflict with the imperial cult for the same reason the Tribunal temple and the imperial cult weren't best of buddies in Morrowind. Essentially they worship different gods/different versions of the same gods, and they will inevitably disagree with each other.
15.06.2007 22:47 Alasdair is offline Send an Email to Alasdair Search for Posts by Alasdair Add Alasdair to your Buddy List View the MSN Profile for Alasdair
Psychotic
Jarl of Skyrim


images/avatars/avatar-1933.jpg

Registration Date: 30.07.2006
Posts: 3,420
Location: Sheogorath's Realm

Reply to this Post Post Reply with Quote Edit/Delete Posts Report Post to a Moderator       Go to the top of this page

I'd also image there would be a conflict with the Mages' Guild because The Order of Oak and Thorn would not approve of the magic endorsed by the Mages' Guild (since what the order does is probably not promoted as magic). Also it was decided a long time ago that the Mages' Guild should have an interest in the secrets of the order... just a scholarly interest of course (or so it would seem). This is another reason why the order would not look kindly on the Mages' Guild

This post has been edited 1 time(s), it was last edited by Psychotic: 15.06.2007 23:20.

15.06.2007 23:18 Psychotic is offline Send an Email to Psychotic Search for Posts by Psychotic Add Psychotic to your Buddy List Add Psychotic to your Contact List View the MSN Profile for Psychotic
The Old Ye Bard
Princess


images/avatars/avatar-3264.gif

Registration Date: 25.05.2006
Posts: 3,396

Reply to this Post Post Reply with Quote Edit/Delete Posts Report Post to a Moderator       Go to the top of this page

As I said ages ago, this faction needed to be split up, because the gods of the Skyrim pantheon are worshipped sepeartely (which is in lore).
16.06.2007 01:09 The Old Ye Bard is offline Send an Email to The Old Ye Bard Search for Posts by The Old Ye Bard Add The Old Ye Bard to your Buddy List View the MSN Profile for The Old Ye Bard
Siegfried
Archduke


images/avatars/avatar-3174.jpg

Registration Date: 07.03.2006
Posts: 2,598
Location: With Your Mom...

Reply to this Post Post Reply with Quote Edit/Delete Posts Report Post to a Moderator       Go to the top of this page

First off great questions Psychotic, they are all things necessary to be asked, and now my brain is going.

quote:
Originally posted by Psychotic
Before I add ideas of my own I have a few questions:
- What is the purpose of the order? Do they seek to spiritually guide the people of Skyrim or do they do what they do only for themselves?

The Order's purpose is to some extent to guide and educate the people about the gods, but at their core their purpose is more "practical". They understand "Runemaul"-- the knowledge of how to wield the power of runes. They use there powers to look after the people of Skyrim-- heal the sick, look into the future, and when necessity calls, combat evil.
quote:
- If the order does serve the people to some extent how do they (the people) interact with the order and how do they participate in the rituals of the order (Do they go to the local stone circle on Sundas to dance and drink in honor of the gods? :D )?

Frankly I haven't thought that out too much. I think to some extent the Order preaches to the lay-people at the places of meeting, and instructs them in the various rituals that compose Skyrim religion (dancing around stones, sacrifices, how to please the gods, ect, ect)
quote:
- Does the order claim to be able to communicate with the gods and if so is this claim real?

The Order claims to carry out the will of the gods more or less-- the validity of the claim is up to debate, to some extent they do, but because of the nature of the Aedra and how withdrawn they are from the day-to-day lives of men, it's difficult to truly tell. About direct communication, it's on an individual basis, generally seers are considered to be in communication with the gods, some are, and others are just frauds.
quote:
- Does the order favor one Nordic god over all other or are they all equally worshiped and respected?

As a whole the order does not favor a specific god, however regionally different groups are devoted to different deities-- sort of like different cathedrals around Cyrodiil are each devoted to a different member of the Nine.
quote:
- In Nordic lore only shamans are mentioned (AFAIK), what's the difference between shamans and druids?

Good question, I guess they are more or less synonymous in many cases, traditionally though in the real world, leaders of the Nordic, Anglo, and Saxon pagan faiths were refered to as Druids-- Shaman was more a thing from other groups, so that's the reason I included them I guess. If they are not referenced in lore, than they won't be in our mod most likely, I was just throwing out ideas.
quote:
- What kind of a role do rangers play in the order?

The Order is not an exclusive ranger thing. Rather, the nature of the Order, and their connection with the "wild", means they generally work hand in hand with rangers. I guess let me use an analogy with the real world to better illustrate the connection. In RL, the Christian Church and Salvation Army often work hand in hand, however, they are two seperate entities, yet in many cases salvo workers are active members in the church-- this is because they have similar goals, and the two organizations can help eachother achieve those goals. The same goes for the order, they commune a great deal with nature, and the rangers spend lots of time in nature, so taking some of the order's teachings and applying it to their everyday lives can prove very useful. I'm not sure I was too clear there, if you have more specific questions, I would be happy to ellaborate :D
quote:
- Precisely what kind of rituals and ceremonies does the order perform (A ritual for a longer summer perhaps?)?

These vary a great deal-- some things like a ritual for a longers summer, another could be a ceremony to please a specific god before warriors go off to battle, communing with animals and trees, hosting a harvest feast to thank the gods for their bounty, a ritual to heal a man from an illness, making an offering to appease a vengeful spirit, or really anything regarding runes and wielding their power.
quote:
- Can the powers of the order be related to magic or is there another way of explaining it (since magic is not very popular with Nords)?

Members of the Order are adept in the use of magic, however, it is generally not something they use a great deal-- and when magic is used it is generally used to augment their existing capabilities, and are used on themselves, not placed on others. Rather, what members of the Order do are create potions to empower themselves, tame beasts to fight for them, craft powerful runes to augment themselves (I'll go into runes in detail in a seperate post later), or via rituals call on the elements, ancestor spirits, and nature to battle their foes.
quote:
- Is there a conflict between The Order of Oak and Thorn and the Mages' Guild/Imperial Cult? If there is one what exactly is the source of that conflict (a question with an obvious answer perhaps)?

Yes, there is a very deep divide between the Order and the Mages Guild, at the heart of which is the mage's desire to learn how to wield the power of runes, the Order's most jealously guarded secret. There is some conflict between the Order and Imperial Cult, however, this more minor and restrained, nothing compared to the quarrel with the mages. They more or less worship the same deities, but look at them differently. Different interpretations so to speak-- its more like the difference between Christian Denominations, they acknowledge their common roots, but differ philosophically.

Alasdair's comment also brings up a good point about the two sides-- here is the fundamental difference in their views on magic use. The Order of Oak and Thorn believes that when magicka is used, it should be to bring the wielder into tune with the natural world, so that they can work as one to achieve their objective. The Mages on the otherhand, believe that magic should be used as a method by which to put the wielder in control of the natural world, as a means to reach an end.

Lastly, @ TOYB:
Ideally the faction could be split up into several sub-groups. However, that is unrealistic from a work-load standpoint if the "Order" is ever to be joinable. To compromise, different halls/chapels/or whatever the meeting places/regional branches of the Order are referred to are devoted to specific deities, but they all kind of cooperate with eachother, share ideas, knowledge, ect.

This post has been edited 2 time(s), it was last edited by Siegfried: 16.06.2007 07:18.

16.06.2007 07:16 Siegfried is offline Search for Posts by Siegfried Add Siegfried to your Buddy List
Psychotic
Jarl of Skyrim


images/avatars/avatar-1933.jpg

Registration Date: 30.07.2006
Posts: 3,420
Location: Sheogorath's Realm

Reply to this Post Post Reply with Quote Edit/Delete Posts Report Post to a Moderator       Go to the top of this page

quote:
Originally posted by The Old Ye Bard
As I said ages ago, this faction needed to be split up, because the gods of the Skyrim pantheon are worshipped sepeartely (which is in lore).

So is there a church-like institution then or do the people worship the gods independently (I imagine it is the latter)? If The Order of Oak and Thorn is not directly related to the followers of the Nordic pantheon I would imagine them being more like wise-men than priests. I suppose their spiritual role should be somewhere in between the shamans and druids of the real world.

EDIT: Thanks for all the answers Sieg, thing are certainly a lot more clear now. Good job!

This post has been edited 1 time(s), it was last edited by Psychotic: 16.06.2007 07:26.

16.06.2007 07:18 Psychotic is offline Send an Email to Psychotic Search for Posts by Psychotic Add Psychotic to your Buddy List Add Psychotic to your Contact List View the MSN Profile for Psychotic
Siegfried
Archduke


images/avatars/avatar-3174.jpg

Registration Date: 07.03.2006
Posts: 2,598
Location: With Your Mom...

Reply to this Post Post Reply with Quote Edit/Delete Posts Report Post to a Moderator       Go to the top of this page

Anyone got suggestions for an initiation quest? I'd like to come up with something very unique to get into the Order. Perhaps a 2 part thing? You start off doing something to gain their trust (any generic mission could work here), and a Shaman and some rangers on a hunt for some sacred beast, and once its caught you take its heart and make an offering of it on the alter of Shor or something?

Any other suggestions?
30.06.2007 22:17 Siegfried is offline Search for Posts by Siegfried Add Siegfried to your Buddy List
cruxvader
Seigneur


Registration Date: 17.05.2006
Posts: 155

Reply to this Post Post Reply with Quote Edit/Delete Posts Report Post to a Moderator       Go to the top of this page

No, many dieties, many factions based on their take of the whole view/ spectrum. That doesn't mean they all are at war, but it does mean that they all have some sort of difference.

If you want an example, look at real world religions, and how divided one becomes.
30.06.2007 23:58 cruxvader is offline Send an Email to cruxvader Search for Posts by cruxvader Add cruxvader to your Buddy List
Tree Structure | Board Structure
This is an archived forum. Post Reply
Silgrad Tower: Oblivion » Beyond Cyrodiil » Skyrim for Oblivion » Skyrim Quests » The Order of Oak and Thorn

This is an archived forum section of Silgrad Tower Forum.