Being a compulsive contributor I am going to go through this thread bit by bit, because although I know you have all traded and discarded some great ideas, there are aspects to both surviving and accepted ideas that have the feel of unexplored potential = they might offer more if they find a new form. Others need to be re-examined.
You may feel that you are past this stage, but I still hope that the following will be of use. What I will try to do is blend all the ideas in an ongoing saga, independently of other decisions so that it can act as either a basis for developement or something separate to bounce ideas off.
Starting with the first page of this thread:
First Commentary - Part One
Vivec and Nerevar
According to TES 4 NPC Lore they have disappeared - that is to say from the view of the common man.
This does not mean that they did nothing before they 'disappeared.' Which opens up the way for video clips and such that are doom or prophesy laden...
Vivec
We know what Vivec looked like - is Ves older now? Maybe Ves has disappeared from view because Ves is worried that Ves aged appearance would worry those who still have faith in Ves?
or maybe Ves has been kidnapped??? = possible cause of war:
by Helseth, a fine reason for people to hate Helseth;
by evil Daedra worshippers backed by the power of their patron;
by remnants of the 6th House seeking to remove their last great enemy;
by the Chancellor who wants to sow chaos...
Vivec might be holed up in a deep cavern - living out Ves last centuries as a hermit. But would that take away the mystery?
What if you combine images of Vivec and images of the Nerevarine as follows:
Nerevarine We have no idea even of the Nerevarine's sex - get real. you substitute your personal vision of the Nerevarine for everyone else's then you p... on all their experiences...
But you can have a shadowy figure in a film clip/vision who sets the scene - ref Azura's visions - with the vocals so distorted that you cannot tell whether the voice is male or female - only that it is under great duress... giving you a mesage of dire import - go solve it... alternating with images of Vivec in an unidentifiable location... you can trust me now - honest... atoning - remorseful ('pologies noremorse, no pun intended) desperate to protect Ves peple but now otherwise powerless to interfere...other than through your dreams... powerful stuff.
Vivec gives you a dream? How? Through a Dream Crystal delivered to you by... NPC X. Dream says Vivec has been warned of cataclysm to come and entrusts this crystal to ... to deliver to ... in the event of Ves disappearance and certain portents that Ves has been warned of...
thus Vivec is there and not there. Welcome to the New Morrowind...da da daaa daaaaa. Usher in the Atronach Quests... a nice little warmer (or is it a cooler?) everything is maleable here...
First Commentary - Part 2
Helseth
Helseth and the Duke are both Hlaalu, and appointed by the Imperials, and Barenziah is always Helseth's mum, loved by everyone. To get to Helseth you have to get to Barenziah = very unpopular move. Didn't you read her life stories? No one hates her, and not only because she has become a peerless stateswoman.
Also she taught Helseth, who is a very naughty boy, but NEVER actually gets caught = the reason why you love to hate him is partly because you can never get to him. Shit floats to the top.
Dream Crystal 2 held by the Athemusa Shamaness (no idea or explanation as to where it came to her from, when or circumstances, just as with Vivec, Crystal says 'am now older and wiser than on arrival in Vvardenfell, have learned much hidden lore, all in the nature of intimations of disaster - consequences of the fall of the Red Tower) = these add up to a 'shady' warning from the Nerevarine, and a call by the Nerevarine to hold a 2nd Grand Council of Morrowind if certain events transpire...such as a comet...
The Grand Council in great expectation and excitement only to be interrupted by the assassins... and
everyone suspects a different group of sending them!
Who dunnit: Maybe this is the work of the 6th House under a new guise setting up the diversion necessary to get at Divayth Fir's research... but lthough they are beaten off, one of them not knowing what he/she/it has gotten ahold of manages to steal the third Dream Crystal from... chose the sender and the holder later.
alternative who dunnit: someone substitutes a fake Dream Crystal that kills the user... cause to be or not to be revealed - maybe the Chancellor's Agents - maybe... chooose...
The upshot is that the Great Houses instead of pulling together, factionalise further... the first rumblings of war...
This would be ironic if there really is a serious reason for the 3rd Dream Crystal's existance = very serious Lore in accord with the best of TES 4 Lore on the 7/8 Towers etc? Lore on this that will have an ompact past the assumption of the Heir esp on Morrowind because of the Destruction of the Red Tower (
some of you may have heard of 1999? who hs posted some interesting speculation on the ES Forums - will post a link here or copy a convenient later)
Who will be the Arbiter of the Council? Must it be Helseth - he is the King and many dislike him, but others support him. The Duke is the Emperor's Local Vvardenfell Administrator, but Helseth is the Emperor's Provincial King. and they are both Hlaalu. On the surface t least they will appear to trust each other though the Duke will be reserved in the face of the dislocation that the Empire is suffering.
Whatever happens at the Council all will agree that any dispute will be restricted to Vvardenfell itself...
more to come...